Windows Phone 8.1.1 and Android 5.0 a.k.a Lollipop have been the best
versions so far for the both Microsoft’s Windows Phone and Google’s
Android operating system. If one were to be simple, one could say that
Android is packed with every feature and customizability option under
the sun while Windows Phone is cleaner, lightweight and more efficient.
But that would be simplifying. Both of the operating systems were
already pretty good and the latest updates bring them much closer
together. So which one is the best? Let’s find out.
User Interface
When it comes to UI, Android and iOS looks similar, they both share
the tried and true grid of icons approach. Windows Phone (or Metro)
takes a different – some may say daring- approach with the user
interface. While Windows Phone has certainly been more beautiful over
the years, Android Lollipop finally catches up with material
design. Here Google introduces more animations and colors to the UI
making Android feel almost as cohesive as Windows Phone and iOS in terms
of design. Without bogging you down in details, the UI of Android 5.0
is beautiful, smooth and colorful. It certainly deserves the name
Lollipop.
Android Lollipop vs. Windows Phone 8.1 – the Start Screen
As I stated earlier, the Windows Phone UI is very different from
Android (or even iOS). Windows Phone 8.1 brings several changes to the
user interface. Microsoft introduced start screen background with
Windows Phone 8.1 which makes the start screen look a lot different than
it was before. In fact, if you use a Windows Phone 8 device now, you’ll
probably think “What, did I really like this UI?” Unlike Android
Lollipop, animations on Windows Phone is an old feature — though, I
would like to see some improvements on animations with Windows 10 for
Phones. Currently, Windows Phone is clearly not as colorful as Android
nor is Android as minimalistic as Windows Phone. Which one you would
prefer is up to you, they are vastly different philosophies.
Features
Windows Phone comes with several unique features. Android, on the
other hand, is filled with tons of features. However, Windows Phone 8.1
lags behind a bit when it comes to features. With Windows Phone 8.1,
Microsoft introduced a notification center, battery sense, Wi-Fi sense
and handful of new features. Google wowed the audience with Android 5.0 —
there is actionable notifications (a.k.a heads-up notifications), smart
lock, improved battery saver, heads-up notifications and much more.
Battery Saver – Windows Phone 8.1 vs. Android Lollipop
So what features do I like on both of the operating systems? I,
personally love the notification center on Windows Phone 8.1. Cortana is
another feature that I love on Windows Phone 8.1. Including that, I
really love battery sense and the data sense app. Windows Phone 8.1
also comes with the ability to change the start screen background –
which I really love to use.
I also love couple of features on Android 5.0. The Smart Lock and
actionable notifications on Android 5.0 is simply awesome. In case you
didn’t know, Smart Lock allows you to easily access your Android
smartphone if you’re near a ‘trusted device’. The actionable
notification is one of the best feature on Android 5.0 — it basically
lets the user interact with the notification. For example, if you’re
playing a game and you receive a message, a small notification will
pop-up at the top of your screen and you can reply from the notification
– without even closing the game.
It’s worth mentioning that Android comes with tons of features for
the ‘power users’ as well. The operating system allows the users to
change the default apps. For example, if you don’t like any default app
on the operating system, you can easily download a third-party app from
the Play Store and select it as a default app.
Android 5.0 and Windows Phone 8.1 brings tons of new features.
Windows Phone 8.1 is a bit behind. Though we definitely expect to see a
bunch of new additions to the operating system with the upcoming
version.
Performance
When it comes to performance, no other operating system can beat
Windows Phone. Android is quite slow and ‘laggy’. I used Android
Lollipop on a Nexus 5, Moto G (2013) and even the HTC One M8. The
operating system was very fast on the HTC One M8 and Nexus 5. However,
the operating system lags on low-end devices like the Moto G. As I
stated, Windows Phone is truly the most optimized operating system. It’s
fast and sleek on high-end devices and even on low-end devices.
Cortana vs. Google Now
Android 5.0 and Windows Phone 8.1 comes with a virtual personal
assistant. Google introduced Google Now with Android KitKat, but Cortana
was introduced with Windows Phone 8.1. Both of the personal assistants
are very smart and cute. However, Cortana is a bit ahead of Google Now
when it comes to reminders. With Cortana, you can set reminders based
on several different things, such as location, contact and even traffic.
App developers can also integrate their app with Cortana – allowing the
user to take advantage of Cortana’s smart voice command feature.
Cortana – Windows Phone 8.1
Google Now, on the other hand, doesn’t come with smart reminders.
However, the personal assistant can remind users based on location (and
time, of course). It’s worth mentioning that Google’s powerful search
features come with the personal assistant as well. Google Now also comes
with an “OK Google” hot-word detection – allowing the user to search
anything pretty easily. Both of the personal assistants will show you
articles, stocks and team stats based on your interests. However, Google
Now takes a different approach and shows different ‘cards’ based on
your browsing history. Though you can add interest to get updates on a
certain topic.
Cortana and Google Now is pretty good, but there are tons of room for
improvement. Cortana is still in beta and Microsoft has been
continuously updating the personal assistant with new features.
App Stores
Windows Phone has struggled a bit for its range of apps. Some of the
popular apps aren’t available on the Windows Phone Store. However, there
are some brilliant third-party apps available in the store. Microsoft
has also produced some great apps and the third-party apps make the
Windows Phone Store much better. With Windows Phone 8.1, Microsoft has
improved the Windows Phone Store with several UI improvements.
Windows Phone Store vs. Google Play Store
The Google Play Store includes tons and tons of apps. There is apps
for almost everything you can think of. The Windows Phone store is more
limited in size, but it also still has lots of great apps to choose
from.. Both of the app stores are great in their own way- Play Store is
already big and Windows Phone Store is getting bigger and better better
very quickly.
Conclusion
Windows Phone 8.1 and Android Lollipop are awesome. Android Lollipop
is a candy land full of color and sleek animation whereas Windows Phone
8.1 is simple, but unique. Both of the operating system has its own
ecosystem, personal assistant and unique features. Android Lollipop is a
bit ahead when it comes to features and customizations. Windows Phone
8.1, on the other hand, is great for performance and productivity. Which
operating system do you prefer? Let us know in the comment section
below.